Should India play with two specialised spinners?  

India should play with one spinner like chawla because shewag and sachin bowl the off spin

Answered by Bharath at 10:33 PM on February 11, 2008

i think,i don't need any spinner.there should be 4 seam bowlers in next match.sachin ,sehwag,yuvraj,gambhir............. ....what about them?they can bowl good.i think,outside subcontinent pitches we don't have any need of spinner in ODI'S.

Answered by rahul , an ibibo Citizen, at 10:24 PM on February 11, 2008

no.in out side in asian contury india play with 1 spiner.in india they play two spiners
(harbhajan singh& piyush chawla

Answered by anil nagpal at 9:37 PM on February 11, 2008

No I don’t think that’s a good idea the basic knowledge I have about the aussie pitches are they suite fast bowlers or seamers .melbourne was suppose to be a slow low pitch but we saw bhajji (got 1 wicket), sachin, symonds, Clarke did not get any wickets though they were economical . we have sehwag, sachin , yuvi to give us the spin option .if we were to take a spinner it should not be on aussie wickets. we have got a inexperience piush and bhajji is not proving to be lethal then why should we opt for two spinnners ?legends say we should picke up the best 5 bowlers for the match irrespective of they being spinner or pacer/ seamer.

Answered by manish at 9:25 PM on February 11, 2008

No, since we already have Sehwag, who is quite a decent spinner and we also have the part-time spin of Tendulkar and Yuvraj.Also, Pathan should be considered as an all-rounder, not as only a fast-medium bowler.

Answered by ankur saikia at 9:17 PM on February 11, 2008

India can play with two spinners if condition supports but first of all india should groom piyush chawla in some less important matches as there is no other emerging spinner. If India plays with five bowlers with irfan batting at no.3 then also in that condition, we can play with 2 spinners. Also we have seen that piyush cahwla is also cpable with the bat in the lower order, so there is no harm playing with 2 spinners.

Answered by Neeraj Jain , an ibibo Citizen, at 7:28 PM on February 11, 2008

no i don't think. because India has many unregular spinner such as sachin, sehwag, yuvraj so its not nessery to have another spinner.

Answered by sameer , an ibibo Citizen, at 6:42 PM on February 11, 2008

i dont think so because our part-timers are doing a nice job.we have seen it in past matches,and in test series as well.

Answered by kunal bhadan at 6:27 PM on February 11, 2008

yes India must have 2 spinners...i know we have sachin and sehwag and we can use them in need but if we want wickets we must have the best spinners........

Answered by akshay , an ibibo Citizen, at 6:25 PM on February 11, 2008

no need of second spinner. as sachin,sehwag can bowl if need arises

Answered by rajat at 6:21 PM on February 11, 2008