Sawaal

Anju Singh's Questions & Answers

47

Rank

21724

3936

102

12

When did people begin to consider Atheism as an answer?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:30 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

Well if i understand your question correctly your asking me how people become atheist, and for me im nihilist (Hardcore atheist) but i just started seeing how if there was a god .. hes hatful .. look at this world, its full of death, violence.. its endless, so much for an "all loving god" eh? but really its just seeing how people are scared of hell and getting out of that trend of being scared of it. if that doesnt answer your question, sorry.
The ancient Greeks began to consider that maybe the gods were just human inventions. Protagoras (490- 420 BC) said: "As to the gods, I have no means of knowing either that they exist or do not exist" which we would today consider to be atheist. He was followed by Aristotle, Epicurus, and many others. There may have been atheists before that, but their names have not come down to us.

Answered at 1:33 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

Is there a part of the bible where satan tries to manifest the logical contradiction of god's alleged omnipotence by asking him to do impossible things?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:30 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

Nothing is impossible for God. Jesus was/is God in Human form. Jesus performed miracles. Miracles are acts that defy logic and science. Jesus did the "impossible".

This sounds possibly like another way of stating the 'can God make a rock so heavy He cannot lift it' proposal. Certainly God can do what is impossible for man. But there are things which are impossible to God such as things which contradict His own nature. Examples of this are such as: God cannot lie. There is nothing that God cannot know, that is, He cannot be ignorant etc. His power is only limited by what is in accord with His own nature and sovereign will.

It is possible that the event alluded to is the temptation of Jesus by satan after His baptism. Jesus manifested a perfect knowledge of scripture which satan deliberately mis-quoted in order to get Jesus to sin. Jesus also used the scripture correctly in reply to satan. The issue in this case was not Jesus' omnipotence as God's Son (God Himself in human form) but His willingness to what satan wanted which would have amounted to submission to satan and disobedience to His heavenly Father.

There is no doubt that in this case Jesus had the power to do whatever He wanted. But to here do what satan wanted (and He was most certainly hungry) would have been wrong.

In any case there is no such thing as 'the logical contradiction of God's omnipotence'. God's omnipotence as well as His love or any other trait one wishes to mention is never exercised in isolation from all else that He is. Thus a loving God sends people to hell because He is also a God of perfect justice as well and has, in His love provided a way of escape for any who want it.

Similarly God's omnipotence is never in isolation from His sovereign will. Thus, even though on occasion He could have destroyed the nation of Israel He chose to heed Moses' intercession and spare them (or most of them). His omnipotence is exercised when and where He pleases and is not subject to the authority of mere mortals. If this were so He would then cease to be God, either in omnipotence and in sovereignty.

So, in relation to the Bible, there are no specific stories which illustrate the proposition of the question, since the Bible does not have material regarding God which is untrue, although it does record the many misdeeds and lies of men, including false ideas of men about God.

Answered at 1:32 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

Do masons know the truth about god?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:31 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

No one knows the truth about God,
although almost everybody claims to.

If the truth about god involves a funny handshake, doing some stuff for charity (but much more for your fellow members), wearing funny clothes, and looking down on anyone who isn't like you, then: yes. The masons have it down pat.

Interestingly, by those criteria, so does the Catholic Church (apart from the handshake).

Answered at 1:32 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read all answers

What are the atheistic alternative answer to the question of the meaning of life?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:27 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

There is none. Life is simply a natural outcome of evolution. The "soul" is nothing more than human's internal perception of complex chemical reactions in a natural body. Emotion comes from natural processes of the neurons in one's brain.

Just because life has no inherent metaphysical "meaning," does not, however, preclude a person, even an atheistic person, from living meaningfully. Humans have evolved into complex thinking and feeling machines, ones that have developed society and civilization in which we have learned that treating each other by certain societal norms allows us to survive more easily in a Darwinistic sense.

There is great joy to be found in our short lives, and one could easily argue that acting virtuously despite no belief in metaphysical "meaning" (along with its associated promised post-mortem rewards) provides a person of nonfaith with even more internal satisfaction than one who believes it's good to act morally because someone (or god) told them they should and will be rewarded for it.

Answered at 1:28 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

Is Alan Rickman atheist?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:31 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

Almost positive he's not.

Answered at 1:31 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

What does God say about human beings?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:30 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

Human beings are created in the image of God (Genesis 1). In that, it is meant that we are like God as spiritual beings and were originally made perfect just like him. However, because of our disobedience we fell from God's grace and turned away from Him thus destroying the relationship between God and humans through our sin.

God's answer was in Jesus Christ, sent to die in our place for that sin, thus becoming the 'sacrificial lamb' who would remove sin and death for ever, restoring that replationship with God through his blood.

Thus what God says about human beings is best expressed in the words of John:

"For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life." [John3:16]

Answered at 1:32 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

Who created atheism?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:24 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

People just came to the conclusion through logical thinking, no one 'founded' it.

Answered at 1:26 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

Are you the only life in the galaxy?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:28 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

Clearly not, as you wrote that. I take it on faith that reality is real, so I assume that you are real too (and not just some hallucination of mine).

If you mean "humans", then I don't know. Maybe, maybe not. There's no real way of knowing until we discover aliens or explore every other world in the galaxy to check.

People try to calculate the odds, but there are so many unknown factors: how likely is a planet to have the right conditions? Given the right conditions, how likely is it that a replicator will arise? If it arises, then you're off, and evolution takes over, and life will grow and change. But we have no way to be able to measure the probabilities, because we know so little about how it all started.

Carl Sagan was once asked that question, and gave a similar answer. The reporter pressed him for a "gut answer". Sagan replied: "but I prefer not to think with my gut."

It would be cool if there was other life out there. I hope so.

Answered at 1:28 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

Definition of people who need to see proof of God's existence?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:23 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

People who need to see proof of God's existence could be considered sceptics or realists, depending on your point of view. Sceptics because they do not wish to believe in something for which there is no proof, or realists because they realise that there is no proof, and can be no proof, for the existence of God.

Answered at 1:26 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

Why do religious peoples go crazy?

Asked by Palavee Sing in Puja & Rituals at   1:23 PM on December 03, 2008

Usha Pal's Answer

Religious people "go crazy" for the same reasons that secular people go crazy. The problem is related to mental health, not religion.

Answer

As above: it's about mental health. Having said that, if a person goes crazy and also has a dogmatic zeal about something (religion, communism, whatever) then their crazy actions are going to be targetted towards and increased by the teachings of that dogma. So you'll hear about religious crazy people murdering doctors, or homosexuals or whatever. It was the religion which

Answered at 1:26 PM on December 03, 2008 | Read Comments [0]

Read answer

ibibo Expert of the Day

65425

9163

a Master in Hyderabad

Categories

Search ibibo
Showcase Talent
Join the group, vote for your favourite tracks & Win prizes.
Star in your own video choreographed by Bosco Caesar
Get shot by Dabboo Ratnani & a 2 year contract with Elite
Shoot models under the guidance of Jatin Kampani
Participate now & Win Laptops, Xbox, iPods & Nokia mobiles
Build your space. Bond with fans. Perform Live!
About Us  |   Contact Us  |   Jobs at ibibo  |   Advertise with us  |  Websites earn revenue  |  Sitemap  |   Terms  |   Disclaimer

© 2006 - 2008 ibibo Web Pvt Ltd. All rights reserved.

Other ibibo services:   Bixee|Onefamily|CrawlX