well ..for all this death life questions ..i have only one thing to say ...the difference between harry potter and other fantasy books is that here repeatedly we have felt the irrevocability of death.those who die ..they DIE.their presence lives but they dont appear magically alive in their physical appearences .we should respect rowling's commendable effort to make us feel the pangs of death and loss in such enthralling and beautiful ways.so let black and dumbledore rest in peace..its harry's turn to fight alone .
Answered by
Anonymous
, an ibibo Citizen,
at
11:05 PM on July 14, 2007