Sawaal home » Knowledge sawaal » Cricket & Other Sports

Jay,
Yes , he is considered out as the middle stump is off the ground if not the bails.

In cricket the rule is subsides with either the bails or stumps are to be removed before the batsmen so in case of being bowled by a bowler if a stump is uprooted instead of bails, still he is considered out.

In bowled or run out either the bails or stumps have to off in this as the middle stump is uprooted the batsman is considered out, if the stumps wasn’t uprooted from the ground and just moved with bails still on the top he cannot be given out as nor the bails or stumps are off.

Answered by: Jateen Gutta at 3:56 PM on October 07, 2008 | Jateen Gutta's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

If the middle stump is uprooted what will be holding the bails together? Though the question is hypothetical, the situation is illogical. But for argument's aske even if all the three stupms are uprooted and the bails are in place defying the laws of gravitation the batsman is NOT OUT.

Answered by: Niraimathi at 1:57 PM on October 02, 2008 | Niraimathi's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

dude.... u forget there is something called gravity..
if the midlle stump is removed, how do you expect the bails to remain in place ???
Neways, although impossible, but if it does happen, the batsman is not out clearly because for a batsman to be out, the bails need to be dislodged.

Answered by: Mehul Shroff at 12:48 PM on October 02, 2008 | Mehul Shroff's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

This is not possible as both the stumps are being supported on the middle stump only.
Ex: Agar apka ghar ka pillar thod diya jay to kya apka ghar khada rahaga.

Answered by: Shubham at 11:51 AM on October 02, 2008 | Shubham's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

It's quite impossible that the middle stump is broken and the bails are still out there. But if that by any means occurs, then certainly it's a great loss to the bowler and an golden opportunity for the batsman. Because as per the rules of the game, unless and otherwise the bails are droped, the batsman cannot be declared as out.
However i have not seen any such instances till now. But we have seen so many instances where the ball moves touching the stumps and the bails still out there. So in that case also the Batsman is given a clear not out.

Answered by: Beekay at 2:08 PM on October 01, 2008 | Beekay's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

No matter if the stump is uprooted but bails remain then batsman is NOT-OUT,Rules say Bails have to go down

Answered by: Naineesh at 9:19 AM on October 01, 2008 | Naineesh's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

It is a very rare scenario that the middle stump is removed but the bails are still there. However, in such a situation the batsman is declared not-out. This is because according to rules, for a batsman to be declared bowled the bails must be dislodged from its position.

Answered by: Pavan B at 11:31 PM on September 30, 2008 | Pavan B's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

It is very impossible but batsman will be declared not out. Because batsman will out only if bails are removed

Answered by: Samir Nagpal at 1:05 PM on September 30, 2008 | Samir Nagpal's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00

well in theory ...no! he's not out until the bails are dislodged, but it would be 99.999999% impossible if the middle stump were removed that the bails would stay in place anyway,some times ball just hit very slowly to stumps and bails remain intact and batsman escaped from being out ,but after remove of any stump it is impossible that bail will be intact.

Answered by: Satyakam at 11:31 AM on September 30, 2008 | Satyakam's Q&A | Report Abuse
Rate this : 00